• Failure: The Key to Success
    James Cameron is, officially, the deepest man in the world. In his remarkable sub, DEEPSEA CHALLENGER, he dove almost 11 kilometers (7 miles) below the ocean surface.

    Photograph by Mark Thiessen, National Geographic

    DEEPSEA CHALLENGE
    The DEEPSEA CHALLENGE expedition is far from over! The project is now in Phase II, a thorough scientific analysis of the expedition's findings. Keep up with the ongoing expedition here.

    DEEPSEA Blizzard
    James Cameron describes what he saw during his record-breaking descent. I have a little camera along on the end of a boom, and I can turn it around and look back at the sub, which I did quite a bit to see what the sub looked like, he says. You could see all of the electrical cables were vibrating, because the sub was going through the water so fast. And I could see little jellyfish and some plankton and so on kind of racing through the light. It looked like I was going through a blizzard. It looked like snow through headlights.

    Day Job
    James Cameron is the Oscar-winning filmmaker responsible for some of the most successful films of all time, including Titanic and Avatar. In fact, the DEEPSEA CHALLENGE crew included technicians who developed underwater vehicles used in Cameron's groundbreaking 1989 film The Abyss.

    By Stuart Thornton

    Thursday, September 27, 2012

    Even though National Geographic Explorer-in-Residence James Cameron successfully piloted a submersible—the DEEPSEA CHALLENGER—on the first solo dive to the deepest known part of the Earth’s ocean on March 26, 2012, the expedition was not without difficulties. The preparation and descent, nearly 11 kilometers (7 miles) to the Mariana Trench’s Challenger Deep, presented challenges and unforeseen complications for DEEPSEA CHALLENGE engineers and scientists.

    For instance, the sub’s arm started to lose power due to a hydraulic leak. This was not a major failure, but still caused Cameron to leave the ocean bottom earlier than anticipated.

    Yet Cameron realizes these setbacks are essential to science and exploration.

    “People think that when an experiment doesn’t give the result that the hypothesis stated going in, that it’s a failure,” he says. “It’s not a failure! It’s an opportunity to learn. You know, we just learned something even though it didn’t happen the way we thought. So it’s part of [the scientific method].”

    Learning from the Past

    While designing DEEPSEA CHALLENGER, Cameron and his crew looked at the problems other ocean explorers encountered on deep-sea missions. Specifically, they looked at the difficulties faced by retired U.S. Navy Capt. Don Walsh and Swiss oceanographer and engineer Jacques Piccard when they reached the Challenger Deep in 1960. On that mission, their vehicle—the bathyscaphe Trieste—kicked up so much sediment that they could barely see anything on the ocean floor. The silty situation forced the explorers to leave after just 20 minutes.

    Cameron says he and his team designed the DEEPSEA CHALLENGER with the experiences of Walsh and Piccard in mind. They built the sub so the thrusts from its propellers would not stir up silt on the ocean floor. Cameron also realized he would have to pilot the sub in a way that would minimize its disruption of the seafloor.

    During Walsh and Piccard’s 1960 descent, their sub’s window actually cracked due to the intense underwater pressure. Cameron and his team took this into account, and created glass-based syntactic foam that allowed the vehicle to compress under the ocean’s pressure.

    “We knew that was going to be a problem on our sub,” Cameron says. “Our whole sub would shrink by 3 inches overall . . . It was 24 feet long, and it would get 3 inches shorter by the time it got to full ocean depth . . .  [W]e had to design every fastener, every hole that a bolt went through had to be slightly oval in shape so that the bolt could move in the hole as everything shrank at a different rate . . . [T]he outer shell would shrink at a different rate than the frame underneath it . . . [T]he whole sub was sort of breathing in this organic way.”

    Anticipating New Challenges

    Cameron says planning for possible failures in any exploration is important. When he lost the ability to control the sub’s arm, for example, it was impossible to collect any more samples from the seafloor. Fortunately, the DEEPSEA CHALLENGE team had a contingency plan.

    “I had already taken one sediment sample, so we had a sediment sample,” he says. “I did that the second I got to the bottom, just in case something like that had already happened. We think about all these things. We think about what the likely failures might be. Well, what if you have a hydraulic failure, and you can’t take a sample? Take the sample as soon as you get there. That was our plan. Just like when the Apollo astronauts landed on the Moon. The very first thing that they did was pick up a rock. . . . They call it a contingency sample.”

    Before the DEEPSEA CHALLENGER takes another dive, Cameron and his crew will analyze all the difficulties they faced on the last expedition.

    “We now have to go back and review what didn’t work in the technology,” he says. “Why did the machine not behave or not do what it was supposed to do? Sometimes it is simple—it’s weather, it’s sea state, something breaks. Sometimes it can be much less obvious—a problem in the electronics or maybe even a problem in the way that we’re operating the submersible. But you build on your knowledge . . . This last expedition was my eighth, so in the previous seven expeditions, I learned a lot and my team learned a lot about what technologies work and what doesn’t work.”

    Cameron even sees some silver lining in the problems he encountered.

    “You don’t know what the failures will be, but you can assume there will be failures throughout or on every dive,” he says. “A light will fail, a thruster motor will fail, and the hydraulics may have problems . . . You can’t do everything on one expedition. That would take all the fun out of it!”

  • Term Part of Speech Definition Encyclopedic Entry
    analyze Verb

    to study in detail.

    anticipate Verb

    to expect or act in advance.

    bathyscaphe Noun

    vehicle used to explore the deep ocean. Developed after the bathysphere.

    Encyclopedic Entry: bathyscaphe
    Challenger Deep Noun

    deepest measured point in the ocean (part of the Mariana Trench), about 11,000 meters (36,198 feet), located in the South Pacific Ocean.

    compress Verb

    to press together in a small space.

    contingency adjective, noun

    possibility dependent on something unknown or uncertain.

    DEEPSEA CHALLENGE Noun

    ongoing expedition to study the deepest point in the ocean, with a record-breaking descent to the Challenger Deep in March 2012.

    disrupt Verb

    to interrupt.

    engineer Noun

    person who plans the building of things, such as structures (construction engineer) or substances (chemical engineer).

    expedition Noun

    journey with a specific purpose, such as exploration.

    exploration Noun

    study and investigation of unknown places, concepts, or issues.

    Explorer-in-Residence Noun

    pre-eminent explorers and scientists collaborating with the National Geographic Society to make groundbreaking discoveries that generate critical scientific information, conservation-related initiatives and compelling stories.

    hydraulic adjective, noun

    having to do with water or other liquids in motion.

    hypothesis Noun

    statement or suggestion that explains certain questions about certain facts. A hypothesis is tested to determine if it is accurate.

    minimize Verb

    to make smaller.

    propeller Noun

    device consisting of a set of two or more blades mounted around a shaft and spun to provide propulsion of a vehicle through water or air, or to cause fluid flow.

    scientific method Noun

    method of research in which a question is asked, data are gathered, a hypothesis is made, and the hypothesis is tested.

    sediment Noun

    solid material transported and deposited by water, ice, and wind.

    Encyclopedic Entry: sediment
    silt Noun

    small sediment particles.

    Encyclopedic Entry: silt
    submersible Noun

    small submarine used for research and exploration.

    syntactic foam Noun

    material made from tiny hollow "microballoons" made from material such as glass or carbon.

    technology Noun

    the science of using tools and complex machines to make human life easier or more profitable.

    thrust Noun

    force exerted by a propeller, gas, or other mechanism that propels a vehicle.

    weather Noun

    state of the atmosphere, including temperature, atmospheric pressure, wind, humidity, precipitation, and cloudiness.

    Encyclopedic Entry: weather
Tell us what you think

Funder

Sloan Foundation